The 13 Greatest Cream Eyeshadows of 2024, Examined & Reviewed

Finish: Shimmer or matte | Shades: 25 | Examined Shade: Trendy Rose | Cruelty-Free: No

Laura Mecier’s Caviar Stick Eyeshadow checked the entire containers for us in a cream shadow, full stop. Our tester, who tried the shade Trendy Rose (a shimmery dusty pink), raved about its creamy texture—she well-known that it unfold merely and imparted ample pigment to create even safety that on no account felt greasy or heavy on her lids.

Mixing was a breeze, too. When our tester used every her finger and a brush to combine it out, she well-known that it on no account appeared patchy and delivered a relentless pigment that layered successfully with completely different merchandise like matte eyeliner. One different plus? The pigment stayed put all day—no fading or smudging, even when she rubbed her eye—and its refined shimmer finish appeared refined and pleasant. 

Basic, we’d advocate this product to anyone who’s new to cream shadows and feeling intimidated by them; its stick elements makes it a incredible throw-on-and-go product, and it moreover works successfully day to nighttime. Our tester is already planning on looking for further shades. Considerably!

Ally Hirschlag, affiliate editorial director: “This shadow imparts an aesthetic glow…I actually like its coloration, buildability, how prolonged and evenly it wears, and the way in which easy it is to make use of. I’m already wanting into looking for completely different shades!”

Finish: Pearlescent | Shades: 14 | Examined Shade: Bare Analysis | Cruelty-Free: No

MAC’s Skilled Longwear Paint Pot Shadow, which is obtainable in a jar format, was moreover an actual standout. Our tester utilized the mannequin’s Bare Analysis shade, a snug beige with a gold pearlescent finish, and was immediately impressed with its comfy, creamy texture. She reported that it utilized simply—she used her fingers and blended it out with a brush—and that she didn’t observe any patchiness until the highest of an 80-degree night. (She moreover has oily, hooded eyelids, so this was a big win in her information.)

In accordance with our tester, this MAC shadow’s shade and finish had been lovely. This specific hue delivered an opaque wash of coloration with a luminous, pearly finish—one which stayed put all day (and night). The matte shades moreover work as standalone shadows and primers for further detailed eye seems. For anyone trying to find a long-wearing, pro-grade shadow, attain for this one.

Caitlyn Martyn, affiliate commerce editor: “Straightforward and silky are the right phrases to clarify this shadow. It delivered the exact shade and finish I needed! It had a pearlescent finish that took it up a notch.”

Finish: Satin to matte | Shades: 16 | Examined Shade: White | Cruelty-Free: Certain

On a worth vary? Determine up drugstore staple NYX’s Jumbo Eye Pencil, a multi-use product that works as a cream eyeshadow, eyeliner, and even an eyeshadow primer. Our tester opted for the White shade, which has a further matte finish, and utilized it as an actual shadow on her eyelids. The very very first thing that impressed her was its versatility and intense pigment.

She moreover reported that this product was very reliable till there was sweat or water involved. It had essential endurance, as a result of it wore nearly all day with out her noticing a distinction. Nonetheless be advised that because of the elements is so thick and intensely pigmented, it could nicely are prone to crease or crush the eyelids if utilized too intently. Apart from that, though, it applies precisely and models successfully—an actual steal for successfully beneath $10.

Tester Shelby: “This product’s thick consistency and extreme pigmentation (as a result of it comes as a stick) allow it to remaining all day. I wouldn’t change one thing about this product; it does its job for the value degree.”

Finish: Luminous or matte | Shades: 27 | Examined Shade: Twilight | Cruelty-Free: Certain

If the target is a further pure seek for frequently placed on, we preferred Nudestix’s Magnetic Eye Shade, an eyeshadow pencil with a creamy, blendable texture and a lighter pigment payoff. Our tester tried this shadow in two finishes—one luminous and one matte, nevertheless every in taupe brown hues—and situated that its comfy texture felt {{smooth}} on the pores and pores and skin and on no account triggered creasing. All through testing, she utilized the pencil on to her eyelid and blended it collectively together with her fingers. 

She moreover well-known that this shadow wasn’t very pigmented; she wanted to use plenty of layers to achieve her desired safety diploma. Nonetheless, for her, this was a constructive—even with one or two layers, its sheer wash of coloration appeared beautiful and pure, considerably for daytime. We advocate this cream shadow comply with anyone trying to find a lighter coloration payoff and likewise for novices as a result of it’s very simple to make use of and blend. 

Tester Katie: “I really favored this pencil’s sheer finish. It made it very easy to get a lightweight wash of coloration on the eyes great quickly. It’s wonderful for an frequently look.”

Finish: Matte | Shades: 8 | Examined Shades: Deep Brown, Warmth Inexperienced | Cruelty-Free: Certain

Benefit Magnificence’s Solo Shadow was our favorite matte chance on this file, far and away. First, its texture was distinctive: it’s a cream-to-powder elements that initially feels balmy nevertheless dries down into an ultra-lightweight powder. Our tester, who tried the shades Deep Brown and Warmth Inexperienced, used her finger to make use of it and situated that it imparted a sheer nevertheless buildable wash of coloration. 

Although she well-known that the equipment course of may set off some patchiness because of the elements dried so quickly, she added that it was easy to create a good look with further layers because of it was so calmly pigmented. Nonetheless as quickly as this shadow was on, it stayed put. She well-known that it didn’t budge all through a protracted night out—there was utterly zero creasing or change. As far as matte cream shadows go, it’s unattainable to go unsuitable with this one.

Lauren Pardee, senior commerce editor: “This coloration may very well be very sheer and matte—I really choose it for a one-toned, smoked-out look. One swipe may presumably be ample if you want a further understated look, or this coloration may very well be very buildable for a bolder mannequin. Each technique, it holds up all through a protracted night out.”

Finish: Matte or shimmer | Shades: 17 | Examined Shade: Crème Brulee | Cruelty-Free: X

For these trying to find a sheer wash of coloration, drugstore staple Revlon hits it out of the park with its ColorStay Crème Eye Shadow. When our tester utilized the Crème Brulee shade to her lids, she well-known that its first layer offered a refined pop of coloration and sparkle, nevertheless that together with further layers imparted ample pigment for a night out or one different huge day. Moreover, as quickly as this product was on, it stayed put; she didn’t uncover any fading, creasing, or smudging after better than 10 hours of damage and tear. (Nonetheless, if she added plenty of layers to create a bolder look, she seen slight creasing/pilling after spherical eight hours.)

She moreover preferred the packaging, along with its ultra-portable jar and its built-in brush (though she hottest to make use of and blend the product collectively together with her fingertips). Basic, we advocate this one to anyone wanting in order so as to add further versatile cream eyeshadows to their make-up bag—it’s a secure stay-put eyeshadow that blends splendidly and is sweet for day-to-night placed on. 

Tester Brittany: “The color was comfy and shimmery—it on no account appeared overwhelming or overpowering. Moreover, the jar it bought right here in was cute and its built-in brush was a pleasing contact, even supposing I hottest to make use of this product with my fingertips.”

Finish: Shimmer | Shades: 10 | Examined Shade: Oyster Pearl | Cruelty-Free: Certain

In search of buildable safety for subtler or bolder seems? We advocate Charlotte Tilbury’s Eyes To Mesmerize Cream Eyeshadow. Our tester utilized the shade Oyster Pearl and raved that its coloration payoff was beautiful—she described its finish as a mixture of shimmer and metallic—and that it was very simple to layer for assertion seems, along with with completely different merchandise like darkish eyeliners. She moreover added that it actually works successfully as a highlight shadow atop completely different matte decisions.

Be advised that barely goes a fantastic distance, though. She reported that this shadow’s creamy texture made it barely powerful to make use of from its jar; it tended to maneuver spherical on her lids and can merely actually really feel heavy or greasy if she used an extreme quantity of product. She added that it lasted for about six hours sooner than she seen any creasing or fading. Basic, we advocate this product to anyone trying to find a creamy, shimmery shadow that blends and builds successfully.

Ally Hirschlag, affiliate editorial director: “I actually like the color payoff of this shadow. It’s very easy to combine out the elements and assemble it up for daring seems.”

Finish: Matte or shimmer | Shades: 29 | Examined Shade: Golden Bronze | Cruelty-Free: No

For a special-occasion shadow with beautiful coloration payoff, go for Bobbi Brown’s Prolonged-Placed on Waterproof Cream Eyeshadow Stick. Our tester, who swiped this product on inside the shade Golden Bronze, well-known that its barely metallic-glittery finish appeared shimmery nevertheless not overwhelming. It’s buildable, too; one layer imparted a contact of coloration and sparkle, whereas plenty of layers created a further intense, pigmented look that was splendid for a night out or a celebration. 

She preferred how easy this product was to make use of—she swiped it on instantly from its twist-up stick applicator and blended it out collectively together with her fingers—and well-known that it dried down quickly. Nonetheless, she moreover added that it could nicely actually really feel heavy on the lids with too many layers.

Be advised that this product may also be very waterproof! Our tester well-known that it didn’t budge, change, or crease even after hours of damage and tear, nevertheless ensure you’re equipped with a incredible make-up remover to jumpstart the eradicating course of.

Tester Brittany: “This eyeshadow seems good for at least eight hours. As soon as I wore all of it day and into the evening, I didn’t uncover any creasing, caking, or smudging, even by the purpose I wanted to scrub it off.”

Finish: Extreme shine, matte, or metallic | Shades: 44 | Examined Shade: Celebration | Cruelty-Free: Certain

We love a multi-use product proper right here at Byrdie, nevertheless Danessa Myricks Colorfix—which works as an eyeshadow and a cheek or lip pigment—stood out inside the cream shadow class in its private correct. Our tester opted for the Celebration shade (a chestnut brown with a metallic finish) and said that its intense pigment impressed her immediately; one layer did the trick for an opaque wash of coloration that stayed vibrant all day and night.

She moreover reported that the elements was easy to make use of and blend. She utilized it with a brush and adjusted it collectively together with her fingers, noting that it was easy to manage sooner than it dried down into its budge-proof finish. Nonetheless be advised that barely goes a fantastic distance, though—even a small dot will do that trick.

Tester Katie: “This coloration stayed vibrant all day; I was very impressed by how rather a lot the reflection of the shimmer lasted on my eyelids successfully into the evening hours, even with out the utilization of a primer beneath.”

Finish: Matte or shimmer | Shades: 8 | Examined Shade: Cloudy Rose | Cruelty-Free: No

When testing the Cloudy Rose shade of L’Oréal’s Le Shadow Stick, she was shocked at how its shimmery wash of coloration stayed put all day prolonged—even with out the utilization of an eyeshadow primer beneath or a setting spray or powder on prime. She moreover preferred that this shadow was remarkably transfer-proof; hours after her preliminary software program, she tried to smudge it collectively together with her fingertips and was unsuccessful.

Making use of this shadow was easy, too. Our tester swiped it on with the ball-tip applicator and blended it out collectively together with her fingers, noting that it felt {{smooth}} (on no account heavy or greasy) and that it glided gently all through her eyelids. For that purpose, we’d moreover advocate this product for novices. Although it’s budge-proof as quickly as utilized, it’s extraordinarily lightweight and simple to manage as a result of it dries down.

Tester Chelsea: “I was impressed with how prolonged the color lasted with out its shimmery pigments ever wanting patchy. It’s very transfer-proof, as successfully.”

Finish: Shimmer and metallic | Shades: 7 | Examined Shade: Plum Pataka | Cruelty-Free: Certain

Discovering a lightweight and long-wearing cream shadow is essential, notably you in all probability have oily eyelids. Enter Kulfi’s Zari Eyes Eyeshadow, a mousse-like elements that, consistent with our tester, felt nearly weightless on the eyelids. When she utilized the mannequin’s shimmery Plum Pataka shade—first collectively together with her fingertips sooner than mixing out with a fluffy eyeshadow brush—she was struck by its daring pigmentation and endurance. Even after hours of damage and tear, she observed utterly zero creasing, smearing, working, or fading.

One issue to note: This shadow dries down in a short while, so mixing quickly is essential, too! (We advocate engaged on one eye at a time, proper right here.)  Nonetheless common, for a lightweight, shimmery shadow with unmatched endurance, go for this product.

Alyssa Kaplan, affiliate commerce editor: “This cream eyeshadow is nearly bulletproof—its shimmery finish stays put all day prolonged with out creasing, smearing, working, or fading. As quickly because it models, it models.”

Finish: Luminous | Shades: 11 | Examined Shade: Strobe | Cruelty-Free: Certain

For statement-making shadow seems, attain for RMS Magnificence’s Eyelights Cream Eyeshadow. Its liquid elements is on the thicker aspect and may very well be barely messy to make use of—our tester found it was finest to dab on collectively together with her finger nevertheless added {{that a}} brush is sweet for precise software program and mixing—nevertheless that it was 100% worth it for its accomplished really feel and seem.

Dwelling proof: When she utilized the Strobe shade, she raved about its engaging, high-intensity pigment and glittery, high-shine finish. Its coloration lasted all day, too, with none change, creasing, patching, or smudging. Basic, for a full-glamour second, that’s the shadow in order so as to add to your cart. It’s splendid for anyone who doesn’t shrink again from metallic shine and loves the drama of a daring, grunge, or futuristic eye look.

Lauren Pardee, senior commerce editor: “This eyeshadow may very well be very pigmented nevertheless you’ll be able to even combine it out a bit to be further refined—each technique, you get engaging coloration and a glittery shine that lasts. That’s the product to buy for a full-glamour second.”

Finish: Shimmer, metallic, or matte | Shades: 54 | Examined Shade: Champagne Shimmer | Cruelty-Free: Certain

Julep’s Eyeshadow 101 Crème to Powder Waterproof Eyeshadow Stick is obtainable in a shade and finish for every alternative, with better than 50 shimmer, metallic, and matte hues on present. Our tester opted for the mannequin’s Champagne Shimmer shade and immediately wished it in several colors and finishes.

Why? When she utilized it with its twist-up stick applicator (sooner than mixing it out collectively together with her fingertips), it glided on simply and felt lightweight on her eyelids. It moreover layered successfully with every cream and powder eyeshadows, along with with eyeliner. Although it required plenty of layers to appreciate true opacity, she cherished its natural-looking finish and well-known that fewer layers would work utterly for a further sheer frequently look.

Tester Lauren: “I’d describe this shadow’s finish as pearly or shimmery; it’s pure, delicate, and flattering. I’d placed on this product alone or layered with completely different metallic shadows for a further dramatic look.”